Hazop Study and Fault Tree Analysis for Calculation Safety Integrity Level on Reactor-C.5-01, Oil Refinery Unit at Balikpapan-Indonesia


  • Silvana R. Dacosta
  • Al-Asy’ari I. I.
  • Ali Musyafa Department of Engineering Physics, Faculty of Industrial Technology Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember Kampus ITS Keputih Sukolilo, Surabaya,
  • Adi Soeprijanto




FTA, HAZOP, Reactor, SIL-SIS, Risk.


plat former reactors are reactors that are in the plat forming unit is designed for developing your specific hydrocarbon molecules that are used in catalytic engine fuel in boiling point range naphtha and fuel mixture to produce components with a higher octane value. Plat former reactor system failure may disrupt operations in the oil processing refinery unit. These circumstances will cause the supply plaformat as products of the plat forming unit valued high octane which is the main raw material of gasoline blending system is reduced. Resulting in decreased production consequency large losses. The failure of the reactor system can also be harmful to the operator, the environment and there is a possibility of reactor unit may explode. To avoid these risks we conducted studies identify hazards that occur in the process rector Hazard and operability (HAZOP) analysis and calculate the value of safety integrity level (SIL). In this study reviewed three nodes Overview consisting of node stage 1, stage 2 and stage 3. Based on the results of identification are thirteen instruments on the third node, which includes equipment; PC-193, FI-005, PC-194 and FI-010. Standards-based Service Oriented systems have Unacceptable risk criteria and the criteria of likelihood 4 Consequences worth three. As for the evaluation of SIL is known that C-5-01 reactor system has two safety Integrity Function (SIS) located in the path of fuel gas and pilot gas lines of the reactor heater. Both SIS has a vote = 1oo3 architecture with similar characteristics, and a review of the SIS has a security level SIL = 2 with a value of PFD = 0.00103.


Arnljot, H., dan Marvin, “System Reliabelity Theory†(John Wiley & Sons Inc., the Norwegian Institute of Technology, 1994.

AS/NSS, “Australian Standard/New Zealand Standard 4360, “Risk Managementâ€, Australian Standard, 1998. [3]

British Standard.,†International Electro technical Commission (IEC) 61511-3â€, England. British Standard Institution, 2003.

Center for Chemical Process Safety (CCPS), Guidelines for Evaluating Process Plant Buildings for External Explosions Fires and Toxic Releases. America: A John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 2012.

Dillon, B.S., “Reliability, Quality, and Safety for Engineers†London: CRC Press, 2005.

Ebeling, Charles E.,“An Introduction to Reliability and Maintainability Engineeringâ€, the McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc, Singapore, 1997.

Fletcher, Lyn E., “Potential Explosive Hazards from Hydrogen Sulfide Production in Ship Ballast and Sewage Tanksâ€, Aeronautical and Maritime Research Laboratory, Australia. 1998.

Gruhn, Paul, Harry Cheddar, “Safety Instrumented System Verification: Practical Probabilistic Calculationsâ€. United State of America: ISA, 2005.

Jeerawongsuntorn. at.al. “Integration of Safety Instrumented System with Automated HAZOP Analysis: An Application for continuous biodiesel production.†Science Direct. Pp. 412-419, 2011.

Jin Jianghong, at.al, “Quantitative assessment of probability of failing safely for safety instrumented system using Reliability block diagram methodâ€, Annals of Nuclear Energy 77 (2015) 30 – 34. 2015.

John N. Dyer, Anya P. Raibagkar, Massimiliano Kolbe, and Ernesto Solano “Blast Damage Considerations for Horizontal Pressure Vessel and Potential for Domino Effectsâ€, the Italian Association of Chemical Engineering, Italy, 2012.

Montgomery, Douglas C “Introduction to statistical Quality Control 6th Editionâ€, United States of America. 2009.

M. Marshal, Edward and W. Scarp, Eric, “Safety Integrity Level Selection.†(United State of America: Research Triangle Park, NC: ISA., 2002.

Musyafa, A. And Kristianingsih, L., “Risk Management and Safety System Assessment from Power Plant Steam Boiler in Power Systems Unit 5, Paiton Indonesiaâ€, Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences, 7(11) Sep 2013, Pages: 349-356, 2013.

Musyafa, A. And Zulfiana, Erna., “Risk Management and Hazard and Operability Study on Steam Turbine Power Plant Unit 5 in The Power Generation Paiton, East Java-Indonesiaâ€, Advances in Natural and Applied Sciences, 7(5) December 2013, Pages: 510-518, 2013.

Musyafa,A., at.al., “ Hazad And Operability Study and Analysis of Safety Integrity Level Case Study: Ammonia Refrigerant Compressor at Petrocemical Plant†Advances in Natural and Applied Sciences, 9(8) July 2015, Pages: 36-42, AENSI Journals, 2015.

Mustafa, A., at.al. “Reliability and Maintainability Assessment of the Steam Turbine Instrumentation System for optimization Operational Availability System at Fertilizer Plantâ€, Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences, 8(13) August 2014, Pages: 132-139, 2014.

. Musyafa, A. et.al., “Evaluation of the Reliability and Prediction Maintenance on the Air Compressor System in Ammonia Plant PT. Petrokimia Gresikâ€, Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences, 9(11) May 2015, Pages: 853-862, 2015.

Poulose, Smear Maria, and Madhu, G., “Hazop Study for Process Plants: A Generalized Approachâ€, International Journal of Emerging Technology and Advanced Engineering, 2012

Rashid Quiche. Ali A.J Adham.†Reliability of Risk Assessment in petrochemical industries. International Journal of Industrial Management (IJM)â€. ISSN (Print) 22899286e-ISSN xxxx. Volume xx. Pp pp xx-xxJune, 2015. Universities Malaysia Pahang, Malaysia, 2015.

Robert W. Johnson. “Beyond-compliance uses of HAZOP/LOPA studiesâ€. Science Direct. Pp. 727-733., 2010.

Ronny D. Noriyati, et.al...“ Reliability Assessment of Cooling Pump For Parts Inventory Planning in Power Plant System, Paiton-Indonesiaâ€. Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences, 8(13) August 2014, Pages: 140-146 AENSI ISSN:1991-8178. Journal home page: www.ajbasweb.com , 2014.

Silvana D. Costa. et. al. “Evaluation Safety Integrity Level Using Layer of Protection Analysis in Recycle Gas First Stage Cycle Compressor at PT. Pertamina Persero†., Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences, 9(20) June 2015, Pages: 154-163, 2015.

Skrtic, Lana, “Hydrogen Sulfide, Oil and Gas, and People’s Healthâ€, Energy and Resources Group University of California, Berkeley. 2006.

. summers, Angela. “Safety Integrity Level: Do You Understand The Odds?†(Journal of Control Engineering, SIS- TECH solution, LLC, 2000.

. Temilade Ladokun, Farhad , “Accidents in Pressure Vessels: Hazard Awarenessâ€, World Congress on Engineering, U.K. ,2010.

. The Norwegian oil industry association, OLF Recommended Guidelines for the application of IEC 61508 and IEC 61511 in the petroleum activities on the Norwegian Continental Shelf, No.: 070 Date effective: 1.0 2, .2001.




How to Cite

Dacosta, S. R., I., A.-A. I., Musyafa, A., & Soeprijanto, A. (2017). Hazop Study and Fault Tree Analysis for Calculation Safety Integrity Level on Reactor-C.5-01, Oil Refinery Unit at Balikpapan-Indonesia. Asian Journal of Applied Sciences, 5(2). https://doi.org/10.24203/ajas.v5i2.4634




Similar Articles

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.