Both Battles: Ohud and Balat Ashuhada' (Pavement of Martyrs): A Comparative Study
Keywords:
Ohud, BalatAshuhada' Andallsia, Jihad (Strife), booties.Abstract
This study is an attempt to organize a comparison to recognize the points of similarity between both battles Ohud and Balat Ashuhada' from part of causes and results.
It had been clear to us that there is some similarity in causes between both battles, for example vengeance and the attempt of compensating a previous loss either it was for Moslems or their antagonists. There was also some similarity in causes of Moslems' loss, such as violating the military orders, the internal controversy, and the demographic structure of the Moslem's army, in addition to other causes had been shown in the context of the study.
References
At-Tabari, Abu Ja’far Mohammad Bin Jareer, History of the Messengers and Kings, verified by Mohamed Abul Fadl Ibrahim, 2nd.ed., Dar Al-Ma’ref in Egypt, Pt2, PP. 499-500. It will be lately 499-513 indicated as : At-Tabari, History of the Messengers & Kings.
Salem, As-Sayyed Abdel Aziz History of Moslems and their Effect in Andalusia since the Arab conquest until the Fall of the Caliphate in Cortoba, Darel Ma’ref, Lebanon, 1962, P. 144. It will be lately indicated, Salem, History of Moslems and their remains in Andalusia, Mahasis, Najat Saleem Mahmoud, Mu’jim Al-Ma’rek Attari Khiyyah (Lexicon of Hostorical Battles) Amman, Dar Zahran for Publication & Distribution, 1432H/ 2011 A.D., P.102. It will be lately indicated : Mahasis : Mu’jam Al-Ma’rek (Lexicon of Battles: Mu’nis Hussein, Dawn of Andalusia, Beirut, Al-A’ser Al-Hadith (Modern Age) for Publication & Distribution, Darel Manahel for Printing, Publication & Distribution, 1432H./ 2002A.D, PP. 327-328. And it will be lately indicated : Mu’nis, Dawn of Andalusia.
As-Salabi, Ali Mohammed, Messengers’ Invasions (peace be upon him), lessons, examples and benefits, Cairo, Association of Igra’ for Publication , Distribution, and Translation, 1428H./2007 A.D., PP. 92-93. It will be lately indicated : As-Salabi, the Messenger’s Invasions.
As-Salabi, Messenger’s Invasions, P. 94; Amabarkfouri Safiy Ar-Rahman, Sealed nectar (a research in the Prophetic Biography “peace be upon himâ€), Qatar, Ministry of Wagf and Islamic Affairs, 1428H./ 2007 A.D., P. 250, It will be lately indicated: Al-Mibarkfouri, the sealed Nectar.
Al-Mibarkfouri, the Sealed Nectar, P. 250.
Al-Wagidi, Mohammed Bin Omar, Book Morals, verified by Marsden Johns, 3rd. ed., 1404 H./1984, Darel Kotob, Part1, PP.207-208. It will be lately indicated : as Alwagidi, Book of Morals.
As-Salabi, Messenger’s Invasions, PP. 95-96.
Ibn Katheer, Abul Fida’ Ismael, Beginning and End. Verified by Mahmoud Abdel Qader Al-Arnaout, revised by Abdel Qader Al-Arnaout and Bashar A’wwad Ma’roof, 2nd.,ed., Damascus- Beirut, Dar Ibn Katheer for Printing and Publication 1431H./2010A.D, part 4. P.176. It will be lately indication : Ibn Katheer, Beginning and End; Ibn Hisham, The Prophetic Biography, verified by Mustafa As-Sagga and Ibrahim Al-Abyari, and Abdel Hafeez Shalabi, 2nd ed., company of library and Mustafa Al-Babi Al-Halabi and his sons, 1375 H./1955 A.D., Vol. 2, part 2, P. 63. It will be lately indicated Ibn Hisham, Prophetic Biography, Al-Wagidi, Bookm of Morals, part 1, PP. 210-212.
Al-Wagidi, Book of Morals, Part 1, P. 213.
Ibid, part 1, P. 215; Ibn Katheer Beginning & End, part 4, PP. 178-179; Attabari, History of Messengers & Kings, part 2, P.505, Almbarkfouri, Sealed Nectar, P. 252.
Al-Wagidi, Book of Morals, part 1, P. 220; As-Salabi, The Messenger’s Invasions, P. 102.
Ibn Hajar Al-Asgalani, Shihab Al-Deen Abul Fadel Ahmad Bin Ali, Accuracy In Distinguishing the Companions, verified by Taha Mohammed Az-Zeini, Cairo, Library of Ibn Taymeyah, 141 H./1993 A.D., part 6, P. 33. It will be lately indicated : Al-A’sgalani, Accuracy .
As-Salabi, The Messenger’s Invasions, P. 103.
At-Tabari, History of Messengers and Kings, part 2, P. 507.
Al-Wagidi, Book of Morals, part 1, PP. 221-222.
Almbarkfouri, Sealed Nectar, PP. 257-258.
At-Tabari, History of Messengers and Kings, part 2, P. 508; Ibn Hisham, Prophetic Biography, Vol. 2, part 2, PP. 65-67; Ibn Hmeid, Saleh Bin Abdullah (Mushrif) Encyclopedia of Freshness of ease in Noble Deeds of the Reverened Messengers of God’s Ethics, 4th. Ed., Jeddah, Dar Al-Waseela for Publication and Distribution, part 1, P. 303. It will be lately indicated : Freshness of ease; As-Salabi, The Messenger’s Invasions, p.105; Almubarkfouri, Sealed Nectar, PP. 259-261.
At-Tabari, History of Messengers and Kings, part 2, P. 513 .
Ibn Hajar Al-A’sgalani, Ahmed Bin Ali, Fathel Bari in paraphrasing the Shaheed of the Imam Abi Abdullah Mohammed Bin Ismael Al-Bukhari, Al-Maktaba As-Salafeyah, part 6y, P.346. It will be lately indicated : Ibn Hajar Al-A’sgalani, Fathel Bari.
Ibid, Hadiths: 3039, 4043, 4067, 4561. For more details see: Ibn A’sem An-Nimri, Abu Omar Yousef Bin Abdullah Bin Mohammed Bin Abde Bir, Ad-Durar fi Ikhtisar Al-Maghazi Was-Siyar (Pearls in Summarizing Invasions and Biographies), verified by Shawgi Deif, 2nd. dd., Cairo, 1403 H., PP. 147-148. It will be lately indicated : Ibn A’sem An-Nimri, pearls in summarizing Invasions and Biographies.
For more details : see ! Al-Wagidi, Book of Morals, part 1, PP.229-234.
Aslabi, Messenger’s Invasions. P. 109.
Ibn Hisham, Prophetic Biography, vol. 2, part 2, P.81; and see: Al-Wagidi, Book of Morals, part 1, P. 232, Ibn A’sem An-Nimri, Pearls in summarizing Invasions and Biographies, PP. 148-150; Almbarkfouri, Sealed Nectar, PP. 265-266.
Ibn A’thari Al-Marakishi, Al-Bayan Mughareb in News of Andalusia and Al-Maghreb, part 2, verified by Kolan, G.S.W. Provincial, A. Leivi, 2nd. ed., Beirut, Dar Ath-gafah 1400H./ 1980 A.D., P. 28. It will be lately indicated: Ibn Q’thri, Al-Bayan Al-Mughareb; A’nan, Mohammed Abdullah, State Of Islam in Andalusia.
Al-Mugri, Sheikh Ahmad Bin Mohammed Al-Mugri At-Tilmisani, scent fragrance from the Wet-Branch of Andalusia, verified by Ihsan A’bbas, Beirut, Dar Sader, 1408H/ 1988 A.D., part 3, pp. 14-15. It will be indicated lately : Al-Mugri, scent of Fragrance.
Ibid, part 3, P. 15; A’nan, State of Islam in Andalusia, part 1, P. 81; Al-Hijji, Abdel Rahman Ali, Andalusian History from the Islamic conquest Until the Fall of Ghirnata 92-897H. (711-1492 A.D.), 2nd.ed., Darel Galam, Damascus – Beirut, 1402H./ 1981 A.D., P. 185. It will be lately indicated : Al-Hiiji, The Andalusian History.
Ibn A’thari, Al-Bayan Al-Mughreb, part 2, pp. 26-27, Al-Mugiri, scent of Fragrance, part 3, p. 16; Al-Hijji, The Andalusian History, P. 190; A’nan, Sate of Islam in Andalusia, Part 1, P.82.
Al-Mugri, Scent of Fragrance, part 3, P. 16; Ibn A’thari, Al-Bayan Al-Mughareb, part 2, P. 27; Salem , History of Moslems and their Effects in Andalusia, PP. 133-139; Taha, Abdel Wahid Thanoon, Arab Islamic conquest and stabilization in North Africa and Andalusia, Beirut, Dar Al-Madar Al-Islami, 2004, P. 297. It will be lately indicated : Taha, Stabilization and conquest; Hatamleh, Mohammed Abdo, Andalusia: the History, Civilization, and ordeal : a Comprehensive Study, Amman, Ad-Dostour Commercial Printing Press, 2000, 114-115. It will be lately indicated : Hatamleh, Andalusia.
Al-Mugri; Scent of Fragrance, part 3, P. 17; Ibn A’thari, Al-Bayan Al-Mughreb, part 2, P. 27; Hatamleh, Andalusia, P116.
Ibn Al-Quteyah, Abu Baker Mohammed Bin Omar, History of Conquering Andalusia, verified by Abdullah Anees At-Tabba’, Beirut, Dar An-Nasher liljamiyeen, P. 39, It will be lately indicated : Ibn Al-Qoueyah, History of Conquering Andalusia; Unknown, News collected on Andalusia Conquest and mentioning its Princes (may God bless their souls) and wars prevailing among them, Majreed, Readineer Press, 1867, P.24. It will be lately indicated : Unknown, Collected News; Hatamleh, Andalusia, P. 116.
Al-Mugri, Scent of Fragrance, part 3, p. 18; A’thari, Al-Bayan Al-Mughareb, part 2, p. 27, Ibn Al-Gouteyah. History of Conquering Andalusia, P. 39; Hatamleh, Andalusia, P. 117.
Al-Mugari, Scent of Fragrance, part 3, P. 18; Ibn A’thari, Al-Bayan Al-Mughareb, Part 2, P. 28; Hatamleh, Andalusia, P.118; Taha, Conquest and Stabilization, PP. 298-299.
Hatamleh, Andalusia, PP. 118-119.
Ibn A’thari, Al-Bayan Al-Mughareb, part 2, P. 28, Al-Mugari, Scent of Fragrance, Part 3, P. 18; Al-Hajji, Andalusian History, PP. 192-193; Hatamleh, Andalusia, PP. 119-120.
Taha, Conquest and Stabilization, 300.
Unknown, Collected News, P. 25; Ibn Abdel Hakem, Abul Qasem Abdel Rahman Bin Abdullah, Conquests of Africa and Andalusia, Taha, Conquest and Stabilization. P. 300; Hatamleh, Andalusia, P. 122.
Al-Ghneimi, Abdel Fattah Mugalid, Battle of Balat Ashuhada’ in the Islamic and European History, Cairo, World of Books, 1416H./ 1996 A.D., it will be lately indicated: Al-Ghneimi Battle of Balat Ashuhada’; Taha, Conquest and Stabilization, P. 301, Hatamleh, Andalusia, P. 122.
Mu’nes, Dawn of Andalusia, P. 32; Hatamleh, Andalusia, P. 123; A’nan, State of Islam in Andalusia, Part 1, P. 90.
A’nan, State of Islam in Andalusia, part 1, P. 90, Taha, Conquest and Stabilization, P. 302; Hatamleh, Andalusia, P. 123.
Mu’nes, Dawn of Andalusia, P. 323; Hatamleh, Andalusia, P. 123; Taha, Conquest and Stabilization, P. 302.
A’nan, State of Islam in Andalusia, part 1, P. 99.
Mu’nes, Dawn of Andalusia, P. 324.
Al-Ghneimi, Battle of Balat Ashuhada’, PP. 63-64.
Ibid, P. 64.
Ibid, P. 65.
Ibid, PP. 65 – 66, A’nan, Sate of Islam in Andalusia, part 1, P.100, Mu’nes, Dawn of Andalusia, P. 326.
Ibid, P. 66; Al-Hijji, Andalusian History, P. 194; Mu’nes, Dawn of Andalusia, P. 327; Salem, History of Moslems and their Remains in Andalusia, P. 144.
Mu’nes, Dawn of Andalusia, P. 330; A’nan, State of Islam in Andalusia, part 1, p. 100; Hatamleh, Andalusia, P. 125.
Taha, conquest and stabilization, P. 303; A’nan, State of Islam in Andalusia, part 1, p. 100, Mu’nes, Dawn of Andalusia, P. 330.
Hatamleh, Andalusia, P. 125; Al-Ghneimi, Battle of Balat Ashuhada’, P. 72; A’nan, State of Islam in Andalusia, part 1, P. 100 – 101; Mu’nes, Dawn of Andalusia, P. 330.
A’nan, State of Islam in Andalusia, Part 1, P. 101; Mu’nes, Dawn of Andalusia, P. 330; Hatamleh, Andalusia, P. 125.
Hatamleh, Andalusia, P. 125.
A’nan, State of Islam in Andalusia, Part 1, P. 101; Hatamleh, Andalusia, P. 125.
A’nan, State of Islam in Andalusia, Part 1, P. 89; Hatamleh, Andalusia, PP. 120-121; Salem, History of Moslems and their remains in Andalusia, P. 141.
Mu’nes, Dawn of Islam in Andalusia, P. 349.
Mu’nes, Hussein, Milestones of Al-Maghreb and Andalusia History, 5th. ed., Cairo, Dar Ar-Rashad, 1421 H./ 2000 A.D., P.296, It will be lately indicated : Mu’nes, Milestones of Al-Maghreb and Andalusia History.
Almbarkfouri, Sealed Nectar, P. 273, and on.
Ibid. PP. 285-286.
Ibid, P. 286.
Hatamleh, Andalusia, P. 126.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
- Papers must be submitted on the understanding that they have not been published elsewhere (except in the form of an abstract or as part of a published lecture, review, or thesis) and are not currently under consideration by another journal published by any other publisher.
- It is also the authors responsibility to ensure that the articles emanating from a particular source are submitted with the necessary approval.
- The authors warrant that the paper is original and that he/she is the author of the paper, except for material that is clearly identified as to its original source, with permission notices from the copyright owners where required.
- The authors ensure that all the references carefully and they are accurate in the text as well as in the list of references (and vice versa).
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).
- The journal/publisher is not responsible for subsequent uses of the work. It is the author's responsibility to bring an infringement action if so desired by the author.
